Presidential historian lays out the problem with blaming 'an election on a previous incumbent'



CNN presidential historian Tim Naftali offered takeaways from President Joe Biden's Thursday address following Donald Trump's win over Vice President Kamala Harris.

"President Biden really had two audiences," Naftali began. "In part, this is a pep talk. A pep talk to the members of the administration — apparently, who were sitting right front of him — and to Democrats across the country. But this was also a way for the president to ensure stability. To make clear to every American that their vote not only counted, but it counted for him, and that he would assure the country, and did assure the country of a peaceful transition. He didn't have to say — unlike in 2020, 2021 — but the point was, he wanted to make clear that he is not seeking revenge."

The presidential historian emphasized, "So it was a very successful speech, directed at two audiences. But he said one thing that I think had a double meaning. And he said 'setbacks are unavoidable. giving up is unforgivable. to many democrats, that might be a reminder of his decision to wait late in the election cycle not to run again. It's very Biden. It's the essence of Joe Biden. Someone who has had many setbacks over the course of his political career, but has always gotten up. And what many Democrats, of course, are debating now is whether he should have decided, if you will, to give up the opportunity of a second term, just after the midterms."

READ MORE: How a 'red line' for Republicans sunk a working class policy Dems could have run on: journalist

"I want to say one thing about that," Naftali noted. "Soul searching doesn't imply simply finding one fault. Historically, to just blame an election on a previous incumbent doesn't allow you to rethink the reason why in 2024, Vice President Harris could not keep the Biden coalition. As we see, as we've worked through the numbers, what we're seeing is that she wasn't able to get the same number of votes, and percentage, that Biden had in many counties."

The CNN historian concludes, "I don't have the answer, but the answer isn't simply that Biden stayed too long. We don't know if inflation how far made it possible for Biden, if he'd been healthy and vigorous to win. We also don't know whom the Democrats would have chosen, if Biden had decided to be that bridge to the next generation in 2023, rather than 2024. So there are a lot of unknowns. It's very interesting for me as a historian to see that people are just trying to find one causal explanation for the dramatic reemergence of Donald Trump as a gnash leader, the greatest comeback -- perhaps the greatest comeback ever, certainly the greatest political comeback since Richard Nixon, two nights ago."

Watch the video below or at this link.

- YouTube www.youtube.com

READ MORE: 'Jettisoned a strong argument': Biden aide says this Harris strategy cost her the election



from Alternet.org https://ift.tt/M73eLpU
via sinceretalk

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

PA GOP Senate candidate who says he 'started with nothing' actually grew up in a mansion

Image
David McCormick, who is Pennsylvania's presumptive Republican U.S. Senate nominee, has often suggested he grew up poor in a rural community. But a new report finds that his upbringing was far more affluent than he's suggested. The New York Times reported Friday that McCormick — a former hedge fund executive who lived in Connecticut as recently as 2022 — has been cagey with voters about his childhood. McCormick has tweeted that he was "raised in Bloomsburg working on his family's farm," said on a 2022 podcast that he " started with nothing " and told CBS News that same year that he " didn't have anything " growing up as the son of two schoolteachers. But according to the Times , McCormick's father, Dr. James H. McCormick , was appointed president of what is now Bloomsburg University by Gov. Milton Schapp (D) in 1973. He moved his family into Buckalew Place — the official mansion for presidents of the school that currently spans 5
Read more

How misinformation could shape the Israel-Hamas war

Image
I wanted to interview Nicholas Grossman regarding the role of misinformation in the war between Israel and Hamas. In particular, I hoped to ask the professor of international relations at the University of Illinois, and senior editor of Arc Digital , about misinformation that arose from American reporting on an explosion at a hospital in Gaza. You know what? I ended up repeating a bit of misinformation! I asked him to lay out the facts about a blast that “killed hundreds, including kids,” and he said nuh-uh (not his words). In fact, Professor Grossman said, “there never were hundreds killed by an explosion at that hospital. Media reported that the hospital was destroyed by an Israeli airstrike killing 500, but that was based on something a Hamas-controlled agency said and was never supported by evidence.” Professor Grossman went on to say “what apparently did happen is something hit a nearby parking lot and caused a smaller explosion, most likely a rocket fired from Gaza towards I
Read more

Trump was hit by glass fragments — not a bullet: report

Image
Law enforcement officials have claimed to two different sources that former President Donald Trump was not grazed by a bullet but rather by glass shards. The officials in question told both Newsmax's Alex Salvi and Axios' Juliegrace Brufke that Trump was hit by glass shards that may have erupted from the shattering of a teleprompter that was hit by gunfire. Earlier on Saturday, law enforcement sources confirmed that the person suspected of firing a weapon at a Pennsylvania Trump rally had been killed, as had at least one person in the crowd. Videos showed Trump grabbing his neck after apparent gunshots had been fired before Secret Service agents pulled him to the ground. They then took him away in an armored vehicle to a hospital where he was treated for injuries. The identity of the shooting suspect has not yet been released. from Alternet.org https://ift.tt/ILgqr53 via sinceretalk
Read more